# Reviews **URL:** https://superreps.net/c/watches/watches-reviews/38.md [Latest](https://superreps.net/latest.md) · [Categories](https://superreps.net/categories.md) · [Tags](https://superreps.net/tags.md) --- ## [About the Reviews category](https://superreps.net/t/about-the-reviews-category/53)
**Author:** [@system](https://superreps.net/u/system)\ **Replies:** 0\ **Last updated:** [October 20, 2026, 5:27pm UTC](https://superreps.net/t/about-the-reviews-category/53 "2026-10-20T17:27:56Z")
In-depth, long-term reviews of watches. Use the topic template and its disclosure line. --- ## [Tank Must: AF, K11 or F1? What the reviews say, flaw by flaw](https://superreps.net/t/tank-must-af-k11-ou-f1-ce-que-disent-les-avis-defaut-par-defaut/317)
**Author:** [@la\_tocante](https://superreps.net/u/la_tocante)\ **Replies:** 9\ **Last updated:** [October 21, 2026, 2:17am UTC](https://superreps.net/t/tank-must-af-k11-ou-f1-ce-que-disent-les-avis-defaut-par-defaut/317 "2026-10-21T02:17:25Z")
The Tank Must is probably the most sought-after dress watch right now. A simple shape, Roman numerals, nothing to hide… so every flaw shows. I’ve read a lot of reviews of the three versions that keep coming up: AF, K11 … --- ## [Noob Daytona 116500 V3 with a 4130 clone: what it was really like, according to the reviews of the time](https://superreps.net/t/noob-daytona-116500-v3-con-clone-4130-comera-davvero-secondo-le-recensioni-dellepoca/138)
**Author:** [@bilanciere](https://superreps.net/u/bilanciere)\ **Replies:** 8\ **Last updated:** [October 20, 2026, 9:21pm UTC](https://superreps.net/t/noob-daytona-116500-v3-con-clone-4130-comera-davvero-secondo-le-recensioni-dellepoca/138 "2026-10-20T21:21:11Z")
Rereading the old discussions on the Daytona 116500, one thing stands out: the Noob V3 with the 4130 clone was the reference point for anyone who wanted a working chronograph, before the more recent versions. This versi… --- ## [Seamaster 300M VSF: the old "8800", and what the reviews said about it](https://superreps.net/t/seamaster-300m-vsf-lancien-8800-et-ce-quen-disaient-les-avis/142)
**Author:** [@la\_tocante](https://superreps.net/u/la_tocante)\ **Replies:** 9\ **Last updated:** [October 20, 2026, 8:46pm UTC](https://superreps.net/t/seamaster-300m-vsf-lancien-8800-et-ce-quen-disaient-les-avis/142 "2026-10-20T20:46:40Z")
The Seamaster 300M is not a dress watch, I’ll grant you. But its wave dial and its balance are my weakness, and it is one of the most discussed replicas. One point keeps coming up in the old threads: the movement advert… --- ## [Clean Daytona 126500 with SH4131: what the early reviews said](https://superreps.net/t/clean-daytona-126500-with-sh4131-what-the-early-reviews-said/140)
**Author:** [@subdial\_junkie](https://superreps.net/u/subdial_junkie)\ **Replies:** 9\ **Last updated:** [October 20, 2026, 8:46pm UTC](https://superreps.net/t/clean-daytona-126500-with-sh4131-what-the-early-reviews-said/140 "2026-10-20T20:46:34Z")
When Rolex updated the Daytona to the 126500, the rep version everyone waited for was Clean’s, with a 4131-type clone, the SH4131. Clean is now described as closed, so this is already history: a batch no longer produced… --- ## [ZF Black Bay 58 over the years: what the long-term owner reports actually say](https://superreps.net/t/zf-black-bay-58-over-the-years-what-the-long-term-owner-reports-actually-say/129)
**Author:** [@deepblue\_patina](https://superreps.net/u/deepblue_patina)\ **Replies:** 9\ **Last updated:** [October 20, 2026, 8:41pm UTC](https://superreps.net/t/zf-black-bay-58-over-the-years-what-the-long-term-owner-reports-actually-say/129 "2026-10-20T20:41:16Z")
The Black Bay 58 is a lovely nod to Tudor’s late-1950s divers, with that slim case and the snowflake hands. It’s also one of the most-recommended Tudor reps. There is more detail in Black Bay 54, 58 or 39. I’ve been gat… --- ## [VSF Seamaster 300M long-term: crown tube, rotor and what owners report](https://superreps.net/t/vsf-seamaster-300m-long-term-crown-tube-rotor-and-what-owners-report/109)
**Author:** [@tickbudget](https://superreps.net/u/tickbudget)\ **Replies:** 12\ **Last updated:** [October 20, 2026, 8:37pm UTC](https://superreps.net/t/vsf-seamaster-300m-long-term-crown-tube-rotor-and-what-owners-report/109 "2026-10-20T20:37:51Z")
The VSF Seamaster 300M is in every “best first rep” list, and there was another nice one on the main sub this week. But is it worth it long term? There is more detail in How long does a rep watch actually last. Let’s col…